We watched Charlie Brooker’s Screen Wipe last week. I like CB. particualarly when he makes caustic comments about TV that I watch (his deconstruction of Heroes was hilarious). I also enjoyed the fortnightly tvgohome, apart from the peculiarly male scatological obsession. Comediennes make one tampon joke and are forever after known as only talking about menstruation, but male comics go on about wee and poo and semen all the time forever without comment.
Anyway, this episode was devoted to discussing the recent wave of dishonesty in telly, including the Blue Peter Socks/Cookie scandal. Brooker went out of his way to explain that TV Isn’t True, citing noddy shots, documentaries with the POV shot twice, the faked caravan on fire in Top Gear and the fact that a different Inuit was filmed as Mrs Nanook back in the days of Nanook of the North. I thought he might mention White Wilderness, but no.
His comments on the X Factor “The Nuremberg rallies for the terminally stupid” was amusing but I did wonder if he was underestimating his audience somewhat. Anyone with a centimetre of common sense knows that reality shows are edited to make A Story, that Simon Fuller doesn’t sit through every no-hoper at the auditions, that if you ring an 0871 number you’re going to be charged more than 4p to make the call. I remember watching a David Attenborough nature show about a day in the life of lion in Africa and the accompanying perils and hardships and whatnots. Aged 14 or so, I realised that they’d shot a few weeks of footage and then made up a story to go with said footage. But that didn’t stop me being entertained and a little bit educated by the film. People know telly isn’t real, don’t they? Mr Brooker doesn’t seem to realise that people who believe the X Factor are not the ones who are going to be watching his programme. Late night BBC4 doesn’t really get the same ratings as prime time ITV. To be honest, just as I prefer Peter Kay to Ricky Gervais, I like Harry Hill’s TV Burp better than Charlie Brooker’s Screen Wipe. Gentle piss taking rather than attempted scornful satire. Charlie Brooker seems to be on my list of clever men (always men) who are vastly intelligent but fail to realise that other people may be as well.
Talking of modern culture: Andrew O’Hagan on lads’ mags: However, once again, I suspect that the crossover between LRB and Nuts readers is reasonably small.
And it turns out that I was wrong about Pretty Woman: it’s actually the best film ever made.
Whilst I’m on an O’Hagan tip: brilliant essay on la Moz.